Murder Most Florid.
For your average journalist, the holy grail of stories is the murder.
This may sound crass, but the murder is unique. It beats every other story in terms of shock, impact, and sheer narrative drive. Council business is endlessly complex. Car crashes are sad and messy. Murders might be all of these things, but they are also singularly complete, a fully-formed story in and of themselves. All murders, whether crimes of passion or pre-meditated, happen for a reason. They have victims and criminals, innocents and sinners, goodies and baddies. It doesn’t matter how convoluted those dark hours that lead up to the act are - there is always a shocking simplicity at their core. That is why they are the mainstay of film and television. No wonder newspapers love them.
Most journalists, at least, ones working for regional British newspapers, won’t come across murder cases that often - if at all. But out in the wide open spaces of East Texas, or the urban conurbation of Dallas/Fort Worth, homicide seems to be more common than village fetes.
Recently, I have become addicted to these stories, and more specifically, this kind of storytelling. I have always had a soft spot for this long form journalism. At university, I did work on the New Journalism, the first-person, semi-fictionalised accounts of Hunter Thompson, Norman Mailer, Tom Wolfe and George Plimpton, where storytelling overtakes fact checking. The pursuit of the great American novel has always been seen as the USA’s greatest artistic challenge, but those years in the 1960s and 1970s proved that some of the best competitors were ducking out of the fight and picking smaller battles instead. Lester Bangs wrote little but record reviews, but he challenged Roth and Updike for raw expression and sharp humour.
The masterpiece of the age was, for me, Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood, the true-life tale of two killers who murdered a Kansas family in a bungled robbery. Capote spent months integrating himself into the town, interviewing friends and family, and even the murderers themselves, to reveal the story of what happened in that isolated farmhouse. The book is unnerving, the prose sparse but textured, as flat and as hypnotising as the Midwestern landscape it portrays.
Capote’s natural successor is Skip Hollandsworth. A staff writer at Texas Monthly, he has, for more than two decades, researched and revealed the shame and structure of dozens of murders. Each story is gripping, cleverly wrought, with fragments of dialogue or diary interjected into the main text, a post-modern reflection on the many faces of his murderers, but they always resolve themselves into stark clarity by the end. The characters are all sketched in simple details - no-nonsense cops, or quiet-spoken family men who had issues with their mothers. But they all ring true. All the lives of quiet determination and desperation, lived out by the oil wells and high school football stadiums - they all ring true, because they are true. These things happened, and these things hurt. And it is in writing them that he goes some way towards healing them.
The true-crime genre can often seem a little seedy, the kind of thing you’d find in the back of cheaply-printed women’s magazines, but there is a quality to Hollandsworth’s journalism that earns its place in any publication. He is not a hack, but a writer with an incredible talent for storytelling, a chronicler of people and places who deserves a place at the table alongside any novelist. Read See No Evil, the tale of a creepy serial killer, and see a story as compelling as any shock-horror crime novel or blockbuster thriller. Try Honor Thy Father, and discover a Greek tragedy sprawled across suburbia. It is journalism at its best - it is writing at its finest.
Journalists across the world are hunting every day and every week for the holy grail, waiting to see if it crop up on their patch. But even if the choicest murder appeared in their road, they wouldn’t grab that fabled chalice. Hollandsworth proves what every comedian has known for years: it’s the way you tell ‘em.

Skip Hollandsworth







